327 N. Second Street - Hamilton OH 45011 - 513-896-9930

The Benninghofen House

The Benninghofen House

The structure today known as the Benninghofen House is named for the family that lived in it for nearly three quarters of a century. Interestingly, they were not the first family to live within its Italianate walls.

The house was origionally constructed for Noah McFarland during the first half of the Civil War (1861-63). Some time later, the home was sold to Major John Phillips who defaulted on his tax payments. In 1874, John Benninghofen, a Prussian immigrant, bought the house for $13,000.

John Benninghofen was a prominent Hamilton industrialist. He and fellow opportunist Asa Shuler operated the Shuler & Benninghofen Woolen Mills. The factory produced blankets and woolen felt used in the local papermaking market, and by the late 1800s, wider distribution allowed them to supply 80% of the felts use in Western paper mills.

Most architectural elements of the Benninghofen House are intact. This is because the home was continuously lived in before becoming a museum in 1949. The house and all the funishings represent the lifestyle of a family of means during the Gilded Age. Furniture dates from the mid 19th into the 20th century. Several pieces belonged to the Benninghofens.

Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the house was presented to the Butler County Historical Society in 1947 by Pauline Benninghofen (daughter of John Benninghofen). Through generous contributions to the 50th Anniversary Fund, extensive interior refurbishing and other Projects have been completed.

Are you interested in visiting the Benninghofen House? Please call us at (513) 896-9930 for additional information.

Latest Blog Posts

BCHS Presents “Fun and Games – In the 1800s” and a Free Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Social

The Butler County Historical Society presents “Fun and Games – In the 1800s,” a multi-generational event focusing on the games that children and teens would have played while living in Butler County during the 1800s. “Fun and Games – In the 1800s” will be held 9:30 to 2 p.m. Saturday, August 12 in the front yard of…

Butler County Historical Society Presents “All in a Day’s Work – In the Home”

The Butler County Historical Society will present on Saturday, July 8, the second of its summer multi-generational programs designed for children and their parents or grandparents. “All in a Day’s Work – In the Home” will focus on the common chores that would have been part of daily life while living on a Butler County…

Historical Society Presents “All in a Day’s Work – Down on the Farm”

The Butler County Historical Society will present on Saturday, June 10, the first of its summer multi-generational programs designed for children and their parents or grandparents. It will be held in the front yard of the society’s Benninghofen House museum at 327 North Second Street, Hamilton, and begin at 9:30 a.m. and end around 2…

Historical Society Seeks Memorabilia and Historical Artifacts of the Champion Coated Paper Company

The Butler County Historical Society is asking area residents that had relatives or family members who worked for the Champion Coated Paper Company to consider donating photos, memorabilia and other historical artifacts to the society’s collection. The society has a large collection of items related to the Mosler Safe Company, the Beckett Paper Company and…